Research to Knowledge

External studyInterview study, 2023

Single, without children, and the “balanced mother” ideal at work

Krystal and Julia Rouse interviewed single professional women without children, aged 24 to 44, about work and life. Here is what the study found, and where the evidence ends.

Read the paper
women are childless at midlife (figure cited in the paper)
1 in 5women are childless at midlife (figure cited in the paper)
of them did not actively choose it (estimate cited in the paper)
90%of them did not actively choose it (estimate cited in the paper)

What the study asked

How do single professional women without children relate to the ideal of the working mother who “balances” it all, from their twenties to their forties? And what does it mean for work?

How it was done

Interviews with the 18 women in a wider UK study of managers and professionals, aged 24 to 44, who lived alone. They told their work and life story in their own words, without direct questions about partners or children.

18 women, aged 24 to 44

grouped by age

  1. Early fertility, 24 to 30

    Career and owning a home first. Motherhood is for later.

  2. Peak fertility, 31 to 35

    Barriers become clearer. Still hopeful, solving it alone.

  3. Late fertility, 36 to 44

    Senior jobs, little fulfilment. Motherhood looks unlikely.

What the research found

The “balanced mother ideal”: build a career, find the right partner, have children while still fertile, then balance it all and stay positive. The women related to it differently with age.

In their twenties, they focused on career and buying a home. Long hours were their own choice; motherhood was for the future.

In their early thirties, long hours left little time to meet a partner, and the biological clock was on their minds. Some planned to go part-time if they had children. They saw it as a personal problem to solve alone.

In their late thirties and early forties, most had senior jobs but little fulfilment and long hours, and felt isolated as friends became mothers. None said they did not want children, yet few had other plans. The authors call this a crisis point.

The authors link this to “disenfranchised grief”: grief over not becoming a mother that is not seen as legitimate, so it goes unspoken. Workplace support is designed for working mothers, not for them.

What it can mean for you

Employers can signpost to support communities such as Gateway Women and to counselling, start a staff network, offer career coaching that includes family planning at every career stage, and open flexible working to everyone.

Where the evidence ends

A small group of highly educated UK professionals, nearly all white. The interviews were for a wider study on living alone, and each age group is different women, not the same women over time. Findings show experiences, not how common they are.

About the researcher

Krystal Wilkinson
Name
Krystal Wilkinson
Role
Associate Professor
Affiliation
Manchester Metropolitan University, UK
Field
Work, fertility and perinatal mental health
All research by Krystal Wilkinson

How this connects to Omaia

Krystal’s studies were not about Omaia, and their results say nothing about Omaia’s effect. We share them because they name the workplace gap Omaia Workplace is built to close.

  • Omaia did not fund, design or run these studies.
  • Krystal and her co-authors own the findings and approve how we describe them.

Source and citation

Gender, Work & Organization, 21 September 2022

Solo-living and childless professional women: Navigating the ‘balanced mother ideal’ over the fertile years

Krystal Wilkinson, Julia Rouse

Wilkinson K, Rouse J. Solo-living and childless professional women: Navigating the ‘balanced mother ideal’ over the fertile years. Gender, Work & Organization 2023;30(1):68–85. doi:10.1111/gwao.12900

Read the paper
Type of evidence
Qualitative interview study
Evidence level
Emerging
Open access
Yes
Language
English
Reviewed by researcher
November 2026
Licence
CC BY 4.0

This page is based on the paper above, published open access under CC BY 4.0. Omaia is a non-medical wellbeing service. It makes no diagnosis, gives no treatment, and does not replace contact with a midwife or doctor. Research to Knowledge is approved by the researchers before publication.

Let’s get the start of life right, together

Three ways to start, whoever you are.